“Social media is a very, very powerful tool. It also gives power to tools.” – Chris Young

Or does it? 

It’s been ten years since Donald Trump perfected the art of the online trolling campaign, using his Twitter feed and — with help from his Russian benefactors — Facebook to attack scapegoats and dominate the daily news cycle. It was a clinic in low-cost brand building, copied ever since across the political spectrum, and why not? Effective trolling typed out by a guy with an iPad perched on a gold-plated toilet regularly gulled mainstream media into giving self-serving “news” reams of coverage that would have otherwise cost a ton of time and money to attract

The situation alarmed the likes of Whitney Phillips, an expert in information politics at the University of Oregon, who told Pacific Standard magazine in 2018 “it can’t go on. It’s a danger to democracy and civil discourse.” But online trolling’s eminence as a political tool may have been one of the casualties of election night 2026.

Writing in The Atlantic, Adam Serwer points out how “take inflation,” the phenomenon of  can-you-top-this pot-stirring by online trolls, “can create a false sense of consensus around ideas that seem popular online but are not in real life.” For a while, he notes, Democrats seemed at risk of being overwhelmed by take inflation, elevating politically toxic ideas like “decriminalizing border crossings” and defunding the police. 

But now it’s Republicans who are mired in their own online effluence. “This is one reason the Trump administration is such a mess: To Trump, everyone’s job is to create content their audience will like, not to consider the wisest or best policy,” writes Serwer. “This is why you have Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth and Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. posting workout videos while mismanaging a war and encouraging measles outbreaks. This administration is less about achieving tangible policy goals than about creating the perception that those goals have been achieved and the libs owned through content designed for the more morally depraved audiences on X, or for the validation-obsessed president himself.”

None of the preferred demons targeted by the right — transgender rights, migrants, imaginary commie-extremist-lunatic Democrats — seemed to persuade many voters this cycle, nationally or here in Massachusetts. “In this environment I think [trolling] hurt,” says GOP Senate nominee John Deaton. “Feeds are so saturated with sarcasm and attacks that one more dunk just disappears into the noise.”

Deaton kept his online outreach light and hyper-local, not that it did him much good at the polls. Republican gubernatorial nominee Mike Minogue also left the most caustic social-media trolling of Maura Healey to others, but did try to duplicate Trump’s use of social media to fuel a cult of personality. Unfortunately for Minogue, the advisors who told him his crusade to liberate flavored nicotine pouches from the onerous regulation of Massachusetts’ state government would unleash a flood of support from young degenerates didn’t have the slightest idea what they were talking about.

Meanwhile, Healey left the negative trolling of Minogue over his Trump ties to the state Democratic Party, using her online engagement mostly to build feel-good vibes. 

Social media will continue to be a key strategic device for candidates, and it won’t all be sunshine and lollipops. But the successful trolling on Nov. 3 was often leavened with humor, like Scott Colom’s brilliant “pick another protein” ad in Mississippi. In our heavily online state, it’s worth remembering that only Facebook, YouTube and Instagram are regularly viewed by more than half of American adults. Nearly two-thirds of both Democrats and Republicans say they have little or no trust in information from social media.

As the odor of Ohio GOP Senate nominee Vivek Ramaswamay and his deployment of an alleged child-abuse enabler to attack his opponent Amy Acton fades, it’s worth noting that the repulsive ad — which began as an online troll — blew up in his face; by a two-to-one margin, people who knew about the ad were more inclined to vote Acton.

Maybe political social media trolls should heed the warning we already put on conventional power tools: use with caution.